Caltrain,Â aÂ leader in permitting bicycles onboard transit, has been suffering from its success for sometime. Everyday,Â bicyclistsÂ are denied boarding (being bumped)Â because of the limited bicycle capacity.
The Bicycle Master Plan, unfortunately, will be a big disappointment for some bicyclists who want to see more bike capacity on trains. The plan focuses primarily on bike parking issues. For various reasons, Caltrain is putting the controversial issue of bicycles on trains off the table justÂ like Nancy Pelosi putting impeachment off the table.
Nonetheless, bike parking is a real issue, for me, I would love to bike between the San Jose station and my work place, which is a mile away.Â I would not have to wait for the bus and I would not be at risk for missing my train becauseÂ of a late bus.
However, I really don’t need to bring my bicycle onboard because I don’t need my bike on the other end between my home and the station. GivenÂ the fare structure, I tend not to use the station closest to me (Redwood City), but rather use another one a few miles down (Menlo Park). I can drive to Menlo Park quickly and that station has plenty of parking. Menlo Park would be too far for me to bike on a regular basis.
I have thought about leaving my bike at San Jose station overnight, but the issue that is holding me back is security. At the station, I’ve seen bikesÂ missing their wheels left on the bike racks. Will my bike be stolen or striped apart? At the same time, all the lockers at San Jose has been rented out.
Preferably, Caltrain should have a system of shared bicycle enclosuresÂ at its major stations to provide a balance between security and flexibility. Even thoughÂ Mountain View, Menlo Park and Palo Alto stationsÂ already have shared use enclosures, these enclosures don’t act as a system.Â To get access to one enclosure, you have to sign up and pay at a non-Caltrain entity. To get access toÂ another, you have to sign up and payÂ again at another entity. Ideally,Â I should have to pay one feeÂ to Caltrain and get access to all enclosures throughout the system, just like I do for my car.
For riders like me, it is more easier to bring the bike onboard and occupy valuable slots than to find safe bike parking at stations. Secured bicycle parking can certainly help improve Caltrain access and address the onboard bike capacity issue.
First, myself is not opponent for bike on board.
I believe that some of bike capacity issue can be improved by thier time table. You stated that “I would not have to wait for the bus and I would not be at risk for missing my train because of a late bus.” If Caltrain have express train every 15minutes in peak hour, late bus will not be a big problem.
Current Caltrain schedule, for example evening NB from San Jose, depart each 05, 25, 29, 39, 45. There are 5 train/h but sometimes you need to wait more than 20 minutes. Train spacing is not constant and each train have different stop pattern.
“Baby Bullet SJ to SF within hour” is great. However, I prefer “Express train depart every 15min but SF-SJ takes 65 minutes”. Every 15min (4 train/h) seems to difficult because Caltrain runs 4 out of 5 train runs as express.
If express train runs every 15 minuts, do you still need bicycle?
[…] they plan to present include bike sharing and a folding bike subsidy. Caltrain bike pain elsewhere:Green Caltrain: "The Bicycle Master Plan, unfortunately, will be a big disappointment for some bicyclists who […]