At the last Dumbarton Policy Advisory Committee meeting, the situation looked very grim for the Dumbarton project.  The Alameda County Transportation Commission had decided not to spend any of the measure BB funds on looking into restarting the Bay Crossing project.   And the San Mateo County Transportation Authority had a negative staff report also recommending stopping the project, leaving the policy body no staffing or funding.  WIth this bleak news, the committee sadly decided to disband.
All is not completely lost yet. Â Over the last year, the Menlo Park has been working on a General Plan update focusing on the area near Facebook. Â There has been strong positive interest in using the right of way to connect Menlo Park, which is planning for more jobs and homes nearby, to downtown Redwood City, which is booming with new residential and office buildings. Â Ideas for this shorter, smaller, potentially cheaper West Bay project range from a bicycle/pedestrian trail, to Bus Rapid Transit, Light Rail, or Diesel Multiple Unit shuttle trains. Â There is strong potential for public/private partnership with the corporations and developers in the area.
The San Mateo County Transportation Authority Board did not actually vote on de-funding the project yet. Â The scathing staff criticism by departing General Manager Mike Scanlon had focused on the billion dollar expense and risky prospects of the full Bay Crossing project. Â It did not seem like the board members had actually thought about the smaller scope and lower cost of a West Bay initial project
Until the board votes, it would be possible to reconsider.

Meanwhile, at a study session for the Transportation and Bicycle Commissions of Menlo Park, leading transportation expert Jeffrey Tumlin offered a radical idea for commissioners and community members concerned about the traffic congestion over the Dumbarton Bridge, and the snail-like pace on Willow Road and the other streets connecting the Dumbarton to Palo Alto, Redwood City, and 101.
To address peak hour congestion, Tumlin proposed congestion pricing, which could encourage drivers to shift their commutes off of peak, or to take transit. Â Congestion pricing is used on the Bay Bridge, where it has encouraged use of BART and carpooling, and has been used successfully elsewhere around the world.
What do you think?



Dumbarton Corridor improvements hang by a thread; could congestion pricing help? http://t.co/bLS1sMuzOy http://t.co/5N1Oqhnxsu
Dumbarton Corridor improvements hang by a thread; could congestion pricing help?… http://t.co/EnSkFMVy2v
Could congestion pricing on Dumbarton bridge help restore rail service?… http://t.co/LdqPUayPOm
What? Come on DB unless you can tell the railroads like Caltrain,Amtrak, ACE and Union pacific to have them going through the bridge again please this bridge needs to be reactivated again
I’m very sad about this. I think the Dumbarton corridor would provide a fantastic way to get east bay housing centers to the jobs on the peninsula. We need a good alternative to the bridges. Unfortunately given the lack of comments here or elsewhere, and the massive political and funding hurdles it seems there is little desire to see this through. I just hope the corridor is saved for the future I’m sure one day it will be vital
@Nick This is ABSOLUTELY what DBR is about: “a fantastic way to get east bay housing centers to the jobs on the peninsula” and the sooner the affordable housing advocates get on the DBR bandwagon the better!!!
Facebook will definitely get rail (not necessarily Caltrain) service in Phase I and things are going to start moving now that Menlo Park is in charge and the East Bay is out of the picture.
As far as rehabilitating the old swing bridge, that is precisely what caused the entire project to crater, so the solution is a tunnel and this must be taken into account when we design the Menlo Park station.
Here is what a tunnel might would look like: the train enters the tunnel at 1:15 into the video and emerges 75 seconds later by which time it has reached 100 MPH:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IB1ZXFZjmg
In Menlo Park’s case, the tunnel portal would be @ University Avenue so University Avenue would be grade-separated and the Bay Trail would finally get its connection across the DBR tracks.
There is no need to remove the old bridge for the same reason that the SFPUC have no intention of removing the old pipeline, so the bridge will most likely be repurposed as the first ever Bay Trail.
Here is how the job got done in 6 months (for $236M back in 2003).
http://www.tunnelsonline.info/news/ctrl-contract-320-tbm-finishes-first/
Correction: the bridge will most likely be repurposed as the first ever TRANSBay Trail.
“To address peak hour congestion, Tumlin proposed congestion pricing, which could encourage drivers to shift their commutes off of peak, or to take transit. ”
Is this a joke? The discussion here is to bring transit alternative to the bridge and they are proposing an alternative to encourage people to take transit which does not exist?
The bay bridge has the alternative of BART but if we get off the bridge, what option do we have? Swim? The Bus is not an answer because it is slow, and will sit in traffic like cars.
The goal would be to use funding to pay for alternatives.
In reading about the project I’m surprised that folks are discussing a $10B+ second transbay tunnel but leaving this bridge derelict when it could be rehabbed for under $1B.
@Roland: are you saying that rehabbing the bridge would not be practical after all? I would imagine a tunnel to be much more expensive. Any idea what that would cost?
The SFPUC bay tunnel (5 miles between Menlo Park and Newark) was built in 18 months for $215.3M but it is a 15ft-diameter single bore: http://www.tunneltalk.com/Bay-Tunnel-Nov09-Bid-results.php.
The Dumbarton rail tunnel will be much shorter but it will require twin 26ft bores to accommodate double-deckers and will probably come in below $500M.
The $10-12B tunnel you are talking about is an east Oakland->Alameda->Mission Bay alignment that would include many stations hence the eye-watering cost estimates: http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/SF-mayor-backs-second-transbay-BART-tube-to-6020957.php.
The next Transbay Tunnel will connect the Transbay Transit Center to west Oakland and Emeryville via Yerba Buena island and should be completed in about 4 years for less than $2B :
http://www.thetransportpolitic.com/2010/01/06/crossing-the-bay-again-but-not-necessarily-with-bart/
http://mtcmedia.s3.amazonaws.com/audio/pac_2015-05-13.mp3