Yesterday, Silicon Valley Leadership Group CEO Carl Guardino presented to a VTA Envision Silicon Valley stakeholder meeting, with results of polling for a proposed 2016 transportation ballot measure for Santa Clara County.
Caltrain improvements polled at a solid 73%, for a ballot measure that needs to clear a two-thirds hurdle to pass. Even higher polling results came in to complete BART to Silicon Valley (86%), pave roads and fill potholes (88%), improve bicycle and pedestrian safety especially near schools (84%), provide transit services for the elderly, low-income and disabled (83%), and increase expressway capacity to relieve congestion (83%), and traffic management to improve roadway efficiency (73%). The Caltrain investments would likely include capacity improvements in Santa Clara County (longer platforms with level boarding) and funding for grade separations.
One of the critical questions is the how much funding to seek from voters. A quarter cent sales tax, which would bring in about $3 Billion over 30 years, polled at 71%, and a half-cent sales tax, which would bring in about $6 Billion, polled at 68%, which is closer to the two-thirds threshold.
Guardino was enthusiastic about the higher number, talking about the level of need for transportation investment, and exhorting the region to “go big or go home.” There are important questions about what additional projects would be covered by the higher tax. Guardino mentioned the Santa Teresa Expressway extension, which would increase the mileage of the County Expressway system by 30%. While expressway expansion seems in tension with the state’s mandate to reduce vehicle miles travelled to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, the expressway projects are very popular with voters according to the polling.
At the lower tax level, in discussions in 2014, there was discussion about phasing the BART project, and potentially deferring the Santa Clara station, Alum Rock station, or both. For 2016, the higher funding level is associated with more enthusiasm about the Santa Clara segment, which is popular among Santa Clara political leaders, although it duplicates the Caltrain segment between Diridon and Santa Clara, which is not currently a crowded segment of the line. The relative benefits of a half-cent vs. a quarter-cent measure will be more clear later on, once VTA has assembled and prioritized the county’s list of projects.
Envision Silicon Valley is the brand name for VTA’s initiative to plan for the 2016 tax measure. Previous Santa Clara County transportation ballot measures were strongly led by the Silicon Valley Leadership Group, an organization of the county’s major employers. In 2014, when early optimistic polling led to exploration of a potential ballot measure, the VTA board wanted a more public process, and VTA has been soliciting input from a variety of community groups to gather feedback on the goals, criteria, and projects that should be funded in the Santa Clara County transportation ballot measure.
The Silicon Valley Leadership Group continues to take the lead on the polling, and has historically raised money from its base of major employers to run and pass transportation tax campaigns.






Caltrain polls well in Santa Clara County Ballot Measure http://t.co/hoPtZvHQis http://t.co/DuJlDIlmDR
RT @bayrailalliance: Caltrain polls well in Santa Clara County Ballot Measure http://t.co/hoPtZvHQis http://t.co/DuJlDIlmDR
[…] Santa Clara County Transportation Ballot Measure Polls Well for 2016 (Green Caltrain) […]
If you’re gonna go big, let’s go big and eliminate all grade separations in Sunnyvale, Mountain View and maybe parts of PA.
[…] Santa Clara County Transportation Ballot Measure Polls Well for 2016 (Green Caltrain) […]
This interesting, I remember in the late 90’s when Mr. Guardino lobbied for the first BART sales tax, he indicated that that was all what BART needed. Opponents, however, indicated that that sales tax would not cover the operation of BART, and not many believed them. A few years later we had another sales tax on the ballot for the operation of BART like what the original opponents predicted. Needless to say that north county got nothing of that sales tax, we even lost the Dumbarton Bridge rail connection funds to BART. Recently we were told that the sales tax collected is not enough to bring BART to Santa Clara. Now Mr. Guardino wants us to pay for another tax to bring BART to Santa Clara siphoning off riders from Caltrain. I think north county has paid enough for BART which does not serve our community, and any new sales tax should be for Caltrain and the Dumbarton Bridge rail. BART was a boondoggle for our esteemed politicians. Enough is enough.
So where is the plan showing how Caltrain would spend the new sales tax money…
Bueller? Bueller?
RT @bayrailalliance: Caltrain polls well in Santa Clara County Ballot Measure http://t.co/hoPtZvHQis http://t.co/DuJlDIlmDR
@osum a summary of the @SVLeadershipGrp transpo tax for @VTA @ Envision meeting: http://t.co/tVrq9itq5r
BART/VTA will claim the necessity for the Santa Clara yard as a pretext to go all the way. Anybody who argues the project should be cut short at San Jose (as it should be!) first needs to show that existing yards are suitable to support service on the San Jose extension.
I agree with Drunk Engineer that Caltrain has nothing resembling a long-term strategy. They sure generate a lot of plans and paperwork, but nothing sufficiently visionary and understandable by the average resident.
@Clem: “Anybody who argues the project should be cut short at San Jose (as it should be!) first needs to show that existing yards are suitable to support service on the San Jose extension”.
Not necessarily and here is how this might play out: BART are expected to return back to the Community Working Groups (CWGs) in October with a presentation explaining why they cannot terminate @ Diridon just like they terminated @ Fremont for the last 20 years.
In the likely event that they will maintain their position, they will be presented with an alternative that terminates BART @ Berryessa.
This is not a problem for San Jose because it would be very easy to send the VTA light rail and/or some kind of Sprinter hybrid tram-train down the “BART” tunnels with much higher frequency than BART (7 trains/hour/direction vs. 3 for BART).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alstom_Citadis#Tram-trains