The Federal Surface Transportation board ruled yesterday that Caltrain is a local mass transportation service, and is therefore required to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act, rather than being governed by a different set of Federal environmental laws.
Caltrain had applied to be exempt from CEQA in response to a lawsuit from the Town of Atherton alleging that Caltrain electrification violated CEQA because the electric line would eventually be used by the High Speed Rail service, and therefore the Environmental Impact Report for electrification needed to cover the entire of the High Speed Rail project.

It’s hard to see how this STB ruling would benefit the Atherton litigants (who are trying to argue that Caltrain electrification is the same as High Speed Rail), because the ruling asserts clearly that Caltrain electrification is a local mass transit service that is different from High Speed Rail.
The ruling states that “it appears that the Project is intended only to benefit Caltrain’s commuter operations.”  The ruling agrees with Caltrain’s statement that electrification is independent of High Speed Rail.  “While Caltrain states that the Project would make its line “compatible with future implementation of the proposed California High Speed Rail project,â€7 it makes clear that the Project is separate and distinct from future high-speed rail operations of the California High Speed Rail Authority (the Authority).”
The ruling means that Caltrain is obligated to disclose and mitigate environmental impacts as required by the California environmental quality act (for example to mitigate impacts on trees). But there’s now a federal agency ruling opposing the Atherton suit’s core argument that electrification is indistinguishable from High Speed Rail.  Caveat – this blogger is not a lawyer and has no expertise in how or whether the STB ruling might be used as a precedent in the Atherton lawsuit.




Atherton lawsuit: Feds rule that Caltrain electrification falls under California law http://t.co/KqvzYo2HpF http://t.co/NIXQNQG7BJ
On the plus side, maybe CEQA will mandate on board bathrooms as a mitigation measure? 🙂
Here’s the front page story the San Mateo Daily Journal ran today:
Feds refuse to protect Caltrain electrification: Transit agency subject to California environmental laws, will fight lawsuit
@bayrailalliance Fed says that they’re sep projects. #Caltrain has done EIR so it’s legal. If fed thinks they’re same, then no need 4 EIR.
@joe_goethals @bayrailalliance @Caltrain_News the feds’ ruling also undermined the main claim of the Atherton lawsuit http://t.co/P6c64wNbwh
None of this should affect the deployment of the Caltrain EMUs once SamTrans and their CHSRA “partners” are sent packing:
“All will be electric and almost half will be able to switch between running on overhead wires or – where a line has not been electrified – as diesels.” http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-31831603
“There are two IEP trains – electric and electric diesel bi-modal – currently being delivered by Hitachi. The trains look the same and there will be no need for passengers to change”
“THE PASSENGERS WILL NOT WANT TO SEE BRAND NEW TRAINS STANDING IDLE AWAITING THE OVERHEAD WIRES.”
http://www.walesonline.co.uk/business/business-opinion/uk-government-must-held-stated-9556037
The second quote is of particular relevance to SamTrans’ bizarre planning whereby EMUs will start arriving at the end of 2018 but electrification will not be complete until 2020 at the earliest at which point none of this will help the day a train is done chewing through a mile of catenary by the time the driver figures out what happened.
http://www.mercurynews.com/bay-area-news/ci_28418166/san-jose-separate-power-problems-causing-massive-delays (passengers would not have had to be rescued from the freeway median if the VTA light rail had a backup power supply capable of taking the train to the next station after a power or catenary failure).
Make Atherton the bathroom stop and allow public urination/defecation. Yes this is disgusting, but it is fitting for Atherton, a very disgusting entity.
Jeff, the skunkworks bathroom is in San Mateo, not Atherton.
@Roland, likewise, the public will not accept Caltrain buying Hybrid DMUs, which are EMU + diesel engines + fuel tanks + additional transformer + battery/super capacitor, and only use them for a few years. Moreover, electrification RFP has already been published and bid will likely be rewarded by end of this year, meaning electrification will be completed by 2019, with sections likely to complete sooner, so the new EMU will not sit idle at all.
@William
1) Once again your info is outdated: http://www.greencaltrain.com/2014/11/caltrain-electrification-price-tag-higher-schedule-longer/
2) Every new EMU in the UK will be equipped with a minimum of one diesel powerpack to provide backup power and A/C in an emergency
3) Some EMUs will have multiple power packs to operate off-grid (examples here: Menlo Park Facebook, Gilroy, etc)
4) Powerpacks are swapped as part of the maintenance schedule so they can be removed entirely when they are no longer needed.
5) Powerpacks eliminate the link to electrify maintenance facilities.
@Roland, really? using 2014 info to counter me? The Fact Sheet Caltrain published in “May 2015” says 2020: http://www.caltrain.com/Assets/Caltrain+Modernization+Program/Documents/PCEP+Fact+Sheet+May+2015.pdf
Diesel power parks are not free, and it provide much less energy than the electrification infrastructure, so one is needed in “every car” if the train is to run at mainline speed.
If the EMU went out to bid in Fall this year, it would awarded at beginning of next year, given the typical 2~3 years before first trainset is delivered, adding time need to be tested and modified, the soonest a production EMU can be Caltrain property would be toward the end of 2018 or beginning 2019, still not big enough of timing gap to justify the additional cost of diesel power packs. Moreover, modern EMU has batteries to keep doors operational for a short period of time, so no need for diesel power pack in case of emergencies.
More fact and less speculation, Roland.
@William Kindly help the rest of us understand which part of this article it is that you do not understand: http://tinyurl.com/nzerhff.
Cost per powerpack is $600K or $1M including the 30-year warranty/maintenance contract, so it would be possible to buy 100 powerpacks for less than the cost of electrifying 4th & King before it gets shut down.
Glad to hear that you figured out the dates and confirmed 1-2 years of trains sitting there waiting for electrification.
As far as batteries are concerned, I guess we won’t need lights and A/C as long as everyone can open the doors, jump onto the tracks and walk to the next station, correct?
More fact and less speculation, William
@Roland, if your assumption is electrification is not worthwhile, then your assumption is incorrect. Caltrain electrification is funded and in the process of accepting proposals, so it is a given Caltrain electrification will happen by 2020, with sections possibility done earlier.
Caltrain will not be the first or the last railway to do 25kV 60Hz OCS electrification. With proper maintenance and OCS wires replace at regular interval, the chance of OCS break down would be low. All the “what ifs” on OCS infrastructure had happen on some other railways, and there are standard procedures in place on how to deal with them.
Remember, even at your unlikely low diesel power pack price, they would be bought “in addition” to a regular EMU, and what would you do with the diesel power packs after the electrification is done? Let the EMUs carry them as dead weight? Stop Caltrain electrification so Caltrain can buy your Hybrid DMU? Again, your idea is not only not worthwhile but also inefficient, so stop pushing your idea using FUD.
@ William. Who said that “electrification is not worthwhile” ??????
The real issue is that we need something worth electrifying to start with (Transbay and DTX are good examples but who in their right mind would ever consider electrifying 4th amp; King, CEMOF or Diridon in its present form ???)
Here is an example of something that was definitely not worth electrifying until it was modernized at a cost of $1B by the private sector: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PdTr06tIlA
So, are they going to electrify now that they are done? Answer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiltern_Main_Line#Electrification
With regards to: “even at your unlikely low diesel power pack price”,
“Hitachi Rail Europe has awarded a €200m contract to Tognum subsidiary MTU to supply 250 700kW diesel powerpacks”
($900K per powerpack including a 27.5 year maintenance contract)
http://www.railway-technology.com/news/newsmtu-supply-250-diesel-powerpacks-hitachi-super-express-trains.
With regards to: “What would you do with the diesel power packs after the electrification is done? Let the EMUs carry them as dead weight?”, kindly help the rest of us understand which part of:
“From a maintenance viewpoint, we decided that the simplest solution is a module that we can remove and refit quickly and easily – like a pit-stop in Formula 1.”
“The electric-only versions are each to be equipped with a Powerpack serving as an auxiliary electricity generator to enable onward travel to the next station and maintain an emergency supply for the train’s services if there is a fault with the overhead power lines.”
“The bimodal versions will have three, four or five Powerpacks depending on the length of the train (five, eight and nine carriages respectively) so as not to be dependent on electrified lines.”
it is that you did not understand.
More facts and less FUD, William.
Short version: Caltrain should adopt every latest British fad.
It’s a big world out there, outside the Anglosphere…
@Roland, you are the one that is using what’s unlikely to happen to justify as “trade off” on buying Hybrid DMUs. Do you even know that “FUD” is or just repeating what I typed?
Caltrain electrification is not just for SF DTX, it also supports higher train frequency due to higher acceleration/deceleration characteristic of EMUs, which DMU cannot match. And what’s wrong with electrifying CEMOF in its current form?
Maintaining EMU will always be cheaper then maintaining EMU + diesel power packs, as your Hybrid DMU would be. Caltrain EMU RPF also includes maintenance contract, in case you don’t know.
Again, unless you plan to skimp on OCS maintenance, the diesel power packs will be dead weights. Your trade-offs simply don’t add up, given electrification and EMU as baseline option, your hybrid DMU has the additional cost of diesel pack maintenance, less useful interior space, heavier weight, diesel fueling cost, etc…
Only when electrification not happening that Hybrid DMU has some advantage over existing diesel locomotive + passenger cars, if that’s indeed your real intention.
“It’s a big world out there, outside the Anglosphere…”
Indeed it is:
October 9, 2007
“Trailblazing Technology Enables Bombardier Hybrid AGC To Run Across The Entire French Rail Network”
“Dual-mode (electrical and diesel) and dual-voltage (1500 and 25000 V) technology enables the Hybrid AGC to glide seamlessly across the entire railway network and to access electricity from any available source.”
“French and foreign VIP guests travelling on Hybrid AGCs from Paris and Dijon to the presentation ceremony in Troyes had an opportunity to enjoy this train’s top-quality features and efficiency – in particular the imperceptible switches from electric to non-electrified tracks.”
“21 French regions have ordered and/or operate 698 AGC regional express trains”
http://www.bombardier.com/en/media-centre/newsList/details.1128-the-worlds-first-hybrid-train-built-by-bombardier-officially-enters-commercial-service-in-the-champagne-ardenne-region-of-france.bombardiercom.html?filter-bu=transport
Question for Clem:
Is the REAL reason behind this hybrid FUD the fact that your Stadler buddies were 15 years late jumping on the bandwagon?
“For operations in non-electrified lines is now also a very powerful diesel version (Power Module) available, respectively the resulting possible hybrid versions.” http://www.stadlerrail.com/en/vehicles/flirt-3/
Fabulous! Several countries undertaking a multi-decade process to electrify their networks are getting a leg up on seamless, transfer-free services thanks to expensive and complex hybrid traction technology. Good on them!
Meanwhile, Caltrain’s dinky little 50-mile to-and-fro backwater operation is going to get electrified practically overnight.
Please explain the problem being solved by hybrid trains?
Fabulous!
We matured from
“Latest British fad” to
“Several countries undertaking a multi-decade process to electrify their networks”
all in less than 12 Hours!
Progress at last!!!