Palo Alto Council members seek Caltrain partnership for grade separation funding

On Monday night, Palo Alto City Council heard a presentation from Caltrain regarding the electrification project.  Council members expressed several concerns with the electrification EIR, and also an intention to work with Caltrain to resolve the issues, including working to secure funding for grade separations. 

There is one issues with the visual appearance of electrical station that seems solvable – community members opposed one proposed location, which hasn’t been taken off the list until an alternative has been verified.

There are concerns that the additional service would add delay at the intersections at Charleston, Meadow, and Churchill. For example, Alma and Churchill, without electrification there would be 84 seconds of delay by 2020, and an additional 25 seconds with more frequent electric service.   Council members and community members spoke in support of grade separations that would improve safety and improve crosstown connections. 

Council Member Kniss, formerly on the Caltrain board, recalled that San Mateo County has funding for grade separations because it was earmarked in a ballot measure, whereas Santa Clara County does not have such funding.

Council Member Burt suggested that increased service at California Avenue and San Antonio stations might mitigate some of the car traffic, since more convenient train service will help more commuters choose not to drive.

While a majority of community members (including this blogger) spoke in favor of moving electrification forward while working on future funding, a couple of commenters recommended holding up electrification, in the hope that this would help $500 million or more to be found for grade separations.

In 2016, Santa Clara County will put a measure on the ballot to fund transit improvements.  Palo Alto residents vote, and so do Mountain View residents.  Palo Alto and Mountain View, and their major employers have leverage to affect what goes into the ballot measure.  Peninsula Cities also have an opportunity to partner with San Francisco and San Jose on funding to increase Caltrain capacity and grade separations, so it can keep up with ongoing growth in ridership.

5 comments

  1. What about San Mateo County? There are some grade crossings there that could be elevated too. It will be a lot less expensive with the Bosch Captive Column structural system.

    One good thing about electrification is that it’s quieter than the diesel-electrics, which I can hear from a couple of miles away at night.

    • San Mateo County already has some money for grade separations from its transportation sales tax. This pot of funds was used for Belmont/San Carlos and San Bruno, and there is another round of funding being offered right now, with San Mateo, Burlingame and Menlo Park among the applicants. But this funding will run out without finishing those projects, it would be great to refresh it.

  2. “Additional Caltrain service would add delay at the intersections….” This is related train frequency and nothing do with electrification. Even now, Caltrain can increase train frequency.
    I would like to see twice number of trains by reducing train consist to half (2~3 car). Is this subject to enviromental report?

    • Train frequency isn’t subject to CEQA. People who are worried about train frequency – and who believe that suing Caltrain would cause $500 million plus to appear to trench the Palo Alto at-grade crossings – would want to litigate now, during the 30 days after an EIR is certified.

      However, suing Caltrain will do nothing to make $500 million to $1 billion to materialize. All it would do is harm common interests with San Francisco, San Mateo County, and the rest of Santa Clara County that all have shared goals to increase Caltrain capacity and safety. It wouldn’t do any good and could do a lot of harm.

Comments are closed.